Rated In The Top 15 Resorts in The Florida Keys: Readers’ Choice Awards 2021 LEARN MORE

  • A long shot of the Havana Cabana pool lined with trees and lounge chairs

    Blog

Nearly every big city has their own iconic dish. Here in Key West, one of our most iconic dishes is a dessert! That’s right, our famous Key Lime Pie! Although there are several stories floating around of where and who discovered the Key Lime Pie, one thing that we can all agree on is that it’s a delicious and refreshing dessert! Here in Key West you can find Key Lime Pie in nearly every restaurant, but if you’re not ready try them all, I’ve summed up the top 3 spots with the absolute best Key Lime Pies!

Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe
Located right on the corner of Elizabeth and Greene street, Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe has pretty much everything imaginable in Key Lime flavor. One of their most fun items is their Key Lime Frozen Chocolate Pie on a Stick! Yes, it’s as delicious as it sounds! The homemade Key Lime Pie gets dipped in a deep dark chocolate, twice, then frozen to perfection. This Chocolate Key Lime Pie on a stick is a refreshing, delicious (and convenient!) dessert on those hot island days. And don’t worry about having a hard time finding the shop, just look for the guy on the sidewalk in the chef’s hat holding the pie!

Blue Heaven 
If you’re looking to have a Key Lime Pie for breakfast (no judgement here!), then make your way down to the corner of Thomas and Patronia Street, to one of the quirkiest restaurants in key West. With a beautiful, colorful and shady outdoor dining area, Blue Heaven is a must stop on your Key Lime Pie Journey. Made in house, Blue Heaven’s Key Lime Pie is made with a buttery graham cracker crust, freshly squeezed lime juice, sweetened condensed milk and lots of meringue. You’ll be able to enjoy your pie outdoors to the sound of live music with the local chickens and resident cats.

Salute! On The Beach 
If you’re looking to find a slice of Key Lime Pie away from the hustle and bustle of downtown Key West, Salute! On The Beach is the place to go. Located right in front of Higg’s Beach, Salute is a great spot to enjoy a romantic dinner and dessert. Like Blue Heaven, Salute’s Key Lime Pie comes with a mound of delicious fluffy meringue. Although there are no cats and chickens around this restaurant, you can catch the beautiful Key West sunset from their outdoor dining area while enjoying your Key Lime Pie.

Decorative Illustration

More from the Blog

More Stories

​TAKE A RIDE WITH ME…

​​Since moving to the Florida Keys almost a decade ago, I have had the pleasure of sharing Key West’s most intimate stories with the travelers and guests who have passed through these magical chain of islands.

AMY SE LO SABE. (AMY KNOWS IT.)

One of the many charms of Key West is the celebration of the multiple cultures that live here. People visiting often compare Key West to a mini version of New York City. As you walk through the streets of downtown you will see why. The art, the music, the food, everything that makes Key West, Key West has been inherited and brought here from another place. Almost every type of culture is represented in the less than 2 mile stretch of Duval Street.

THE CABANA OFFERS A LUSH ESCAPE FROM REALITY

Working and hanging in Key West is two different worlds.  But beginning my career at Key West’s newest hotel, Havana Cabana At Key West, changed things for me.  Meeting people on vacation is fun!  This is the old Inn At Key West, a hotel that was destroyed in the recent hurricane and emerged as this new gem!

Best Rate Image
Adults
1
Children
0